ChooseTheGift
Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders — gift idea

Asmodee

Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders

A cooperative Victorian detective game with ten cases of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, for 1 to 8 players aged 14 and up.

#1 of 14 TOP 5
Murder Mystery Games: The 14 Best Detective Games and Case Files for Adults, Ranked (2026)

Among the 5 best-ranked products of this selection.

See the full ranking →
84/ 100
CTG scoreSafe betHow we score
Today’s price on Amazon
$59.31 Price checked on Nov 22, 11:30 AM · Price and availability are accurate as of the date and time indicated and are subject to change; the price shown on Amazon at the time of purchase applies.
Order on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, ChooseTheGift earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. This link does not affect our score.

Where it ranks in our guides

A medal marks a podium; the score on the right is the product’s score for that recipient.

Scores by criterion

Proven reliability 90
Satisfaction and consistency of user feedback over time.
Perceived value 86
How valuable it feels compared with the budget.
Bond and memory 81
What the gift says about the relationship, and what remains months later.
Originality 81
The opposite of the cliché expected for this recipient.
Novelty 70
Age of the product since it went on sale: top score for the first three months, then it declines over time.

Our verdict

84 / 100

It hands a mystery lover ten Victorian cases to solve around a table, so the gift gives several game nights rather than one evening.

Best forA mystery fan who likes to reason through a long case with friends
Best occasionChristmas, birthday
Avoid ifThe person wants a short game to finish in one sitting.
Order on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

How many cases are in the box?

Ten cases for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective.

How many people can play?

One to eight players, cooperatively.

What age is it for?

Ages 14 and up, with about 90 minutes of play time.

Similar products

How we score

The CTG score out of 100 summarizes five criteria rated for every product: proven reliability, perceived value, bond and memory, originality and novelty. The same scale applies to every product, generously, because every product in our selection is already good. The score does not depend on the guide. 60 to 69: average gift. 70 to 77: good pick. 78 to 85: safe bet. 86 to 89: favorite. 90 and above: the perfect gift, a label reserved for excellent products that customers like, one winner per occasion. In a guide, the score for the recipient combines this score with the place in the ranking. The budget is an indicative range: the exact price is shown by the store at checkout. Read our full selection method →

← Back to home