ChooseTheGift

Murder Mystery Games: The 14 Best Detective Games and Case Files for Adults, Ranked (2026)

Murder Mystery Games: The 14 Best Detective Games and Case Files for Adults, Ranked (2026)

A murder mystery game works as a gift when it hands someone an evening to investigate, alone, as a couple or with friends. Our ranking compares 14 games for adults and teens, from boxed cases and cold case files to logic puzzle books, a Sherlock Holmes campaign, a social deduction party game, escape-room card sets, a puzzle box, a mystery jigsaw and two advent calendars: the Winterline Express book and Mystery Hunters' envelope case. They run from about $12 to $60. Prices are indicative and change on Amazon. The advent calendars are one-time puzzles that start on December 1, so order them by November 25.

By ChooseTheGift Editorial Team · Updated November 21, 2026 · How we chose these picks

What is the best murder mystery game for adults?

Asmodee's Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders is the highest-ranked gift here, for a mystery fan who wants many evenings of cases. Murder on the Winterline Express, a 24-day murder mystery advent book, and Thames & Kosmos Exit: Dead Man on the Orient Express, an escape card game, complete the top three. Lucky Duck's Chronicles of Crime and Hunt A Killer follow.

Quick comparison (14)

Rank Gift Best for Score for this guide Budget
#1 Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders Best Overall 98/100 $50 to $100
#2 Murder on the Winterline Express: A Murder Mystery Advent Calendar Book Best Seasonal Gift 94/100 $15 to $30
#3 Thames & Kosmos Exit: Dead Man on the Orient Express Best Escape Card Game 95/100 Under $15
#4 Chronicles of Crime, Cooperative Detective Board Game with App (Lucky Duck Games) Best App-Driven Game 95/100 $30 to $50
#5 Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk Murder Mystery Game Crowd favorite 95/100 $30 to $50
#6 Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft Cold Case Game Best Cold Case File 93/100 $15 to $30
#7 Grey Fox Games Deception: Murder in Hong Kong Best Party Game 93/100 $30 to $50
#8 iDventure Cluebox PRO Sherlock's Camera Escape Room Puzzle Box Best Puzzle Box 93/100 $50 to $100
#9 Cryptic Killers Unsolved Case File, Murder of a Millionaire Best for Digital Clues 92/100 $15 to $30
#10 Mystery Hunters Advent Calendar 2026, The Stolen Mona Lisa Heist Best Envelope-Based Seasonal Case 91/100 $15 to $30
#11 BePuzzled Murder by the Pyramids 1000-Piece Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle Best Mystery Jigsaw 88/100 $15 to $30
#12 Unlock! Timeless Adventures Escape Room Card Game Best Reusable Escape Set 88/100 $30 to $50
#13 Murdoku: 80 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles Best Illustrated Puzzle Book 88/100 $15 to $30
#14 Murdle: Volume 1, 100 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles Best Puzzle Book 87/100 Under $15

The Full Ranking

1
Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders — gift idea
#1 · Best Overall Games & Challenges

Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders

A cooperative Victorian detective game with ten cases of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, for 1 to 8 players aged 14 and up.

Ideal for: A mystery fan who wants many evenings of cases

Why it works: Ten cases in one box · Cooperative or solo · About 90 minutes of play

Skip if: The person wants a short game to finish in one sitting.

Score for this guide98/100
$59.31 on Nov 21, 10:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
2
Murder on the Winterline Express: A Murder Mystery Advent Calendar Book — gift idea
#2 · Best Seasonal Gift Advent Calendars

Murder on the Winterline Express: A Murder Mystery Advent Calendar Book

A Christmas train, a murder aboard and 24 fair-play puzzles to name the killer before the last stop.

Ideal for: A mystery fan who wants a December countdown

Why it works: 24 days of puzzles · Fair-play clues · Low price

Skip if: The gift is needed outside December.

Score for this guide94/100
$19.87 on Nov 21, 08:40 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
3
Thames & Kosmos Exit: Dead Man on the Orient Express — gift idea
#3 · Best Escape Card Game Games & Challenges

Thames & Kosmos Exit: Dead Man on the Orient Express

A card-based escape room at home set on the Orient Express, for 1 to 4 players aged 12 and up, with no app needed.

Ideal for: A mystery fan who wants a quick murder case with friends

Why it works: Card based, no app · 1 to 4 players aged 12 and up · Low price

Skip if: The person wants a game that can be replayed.

Score for this guide95/100 Black Friday −16 %
Black Friday deal $14.99 $17.95 on Nov 21, 10:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
4
Favorite Chronicles of Crime, Cooperative Detective Board Game with App (Lucky Duck Games) — gift idea
#4 · Best App-Driven Game Games & Challenges

Chronicles of Crime, Cooperative Detective Board Game with App (Lucky Duck Games)

A cooperative crime-solving game: a free phone app turns the cards into crime scenes, suspects and evidence.

Ideal for: A table that wants a long cooperative story

Why it works: Free smartphone app · Cooperative play against the clock · Several scenarios

Skip if: The group dislikes playing with a phone.

Score for this guide95/100
$39.54 on Nov 21, 08:40 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
5
Favorite Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk Murder Mystery Game — gift idea
#5 · Crowd favorite Games & Challenges

Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk Murder Mystery Game

A one-evening murder mystery box set at an amusement park, for 1 or more players aged 14 and up.

Ideal for: A true crime fan who wants one evening alone, as a couple or with friends

Why it works: Standalone one-sitting case · Evidence files and crime scene photos · Solo, couple or group

Skip if: The person wants a game with many evenings.

Score for this guide95/100
$31.99 on Nov 21, 08:50 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
6
Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft Cold Case Game — gift idea
#6 · Best Cold Case File Games & Challenges

Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft Cold Case Game

A cold case murder game with over 50 documents and photos, where three clues must clear the convicted man and name the real killer.

Ideal for: A reader who likes to study documents like a cold case detective

Why it works: Over 50 documents and photos · Three clues to crack the case · Rated for ages 14 and up

Skip if: The person dislikes reading long documents.

Score for this guide93/100 Black Friday −15 %
Black Friday deal $16.99 $19.99 on Nov 21, 10:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
7
Grey Fox Games Deception: Murder in Hong Kong — gift idea
#7 · Best Party Game Games & Challenges

Grey Fox Games Deception: Murder in Hong Kong

A social deduction party game with secret roles of Investigator, Murderer and Witness, for 4 to 12 players in 20-minute rounds.

Ideal for: A group of friends who like bluffing games

Why it works: 4 to 12 players · 20-minute rounds · Many role combinations

Skip if: The group has fewer than four players.

Score for this guide93/100
$44.99 on Nov 21, 10:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
8
Favorite iDventure Cluebox PRO Sherlock's Camera Escape Room Puzzle Box — gift idea

iDventure Cluebox PRO Sherlock's Camera Escape Room Puzzle Box

A wooden escape-room puzzle box shaped like Sherlock Holmes' retro camera.

Ideal for: A puzzle fan who likes mechanisms

Why it works: Wooden box with mechanisms · 1 to 2 players aged 14 and up · Can be reassembled for the next player

Skip if: The person wants a game for a large group.

Score for this guide93/100 Black Friday −15 %
Black Friday deal $50.92 $59.90 on Nov 21, 10:30 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
9
Favorite Cryptic Killers Unsolved Case File, Murder of a Millionaire — gift idea
#9 · Best for Digital Clues Games & Challenges

Cryptic Killers Unsolved Case File, Murder of a Millionaire

A cold case in a box: 29 pieces of evidence and an online police inbox to break into, for about two hours of detective work.

Ideal for: A detective fan who likes physical evidence and online clues together

Why it works: 29 pieces of physical evidence · Online police inbox to search · About two hours of play

Skip if: The person wants a case with no online step.

Score for this guide92/100 Black Friday −36 %
Black Friday deal $15.99 $25.00 on Nov 21, 08:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
10
Mystery Hunters Advent Calendar 2026, The Stolen Mona Lisa Heist — gift idea
#10 · Best Envelope-Based Seasonal Case Advent Calendars Games & Challenges

Mystery Hunters Advent Calendar 2026, The Stolen Mona Lisa Heist

A Stolen Mona Lisa case file for Christmas: one sealed envelope a day, witness letters that hide clues, and digital evidence such as recordings, photos and hidden-ink messages that lets you eliminate suspects before a final verdict on the 24th. Optional step-by-step hints keep a stuck player moving.

Ideal for: An adult or teen who likes whodunits and would rather open a heist case than chocolate in December

Why it works: Sealed envelopes and a keepsake crime-tape box · Digital evidence unlocked by solving clues · Optional step-by-step hints

Skip if: You need a game that plays offline or can be replayed: it needs internet for the digital files and is a one-time play.

Score for this guide91/100 Black Friday −15 %
Black Friday deal $23.69 $27.99 on Nov 21, 08:50 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
11
BePuzzled Murder by the Pyramids 1000-Piece Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle — gift idea
#11 · Best Mystery Jigsaw Games & Challenges

BePuzzled Murder by the Pyramids 1000-Piece Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle

A 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle with a story booklet: assemble it to find the hidden clues and name the murderer, for ages 15 and up.

Ideal for: A puzzler who also likes whodunits

Why it works: 1000 pieces · Story booklet · Mirror reveal of the culprit

Skip if: The person has no space for a large puzzle.

Score for this guide88/100
$16.99 on Nov 21, 10:20 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
12
Unlock! Timeless Adventures Escape Room Card Game — gift idea
#12 · Best Reusable Escape Set Games & Challenges

Unlock! Timeless Adventures Escape Room Card Game

Three escape-room scenarios played with cards and a free app that keeps time and gives hints.

Ideal for: A group that likes escape rooms at the table

Why it works: Three scenarios · Free companion app · Cooperative play

Skip if: The group wants a pure murder mystery.

Score for this guide88/100
$39.99 on Nov 21, 08:50 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
13
Favorite Murdoku: 80 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles — gift idea
#13 · Best Illustrated Puzzle Book Games & Challenges

Murdoku: 80 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles

A book of 80 murder mystery logic puzzles that pairs sudoku-style deduction with illustrated crime scenes.

Ideal for: A sudoku fan who likes picture clues

Why it works: 80 puzzles · Full-color crime scenes · Some puzzles add extra rules

Skip if: The person already owns a murder logic puzzle book.

Score for this guide88/100 Black Friday −20 %
Black Friday deal $15.18 $18.99 on Nov 21, 10:40 PM
Order on Amazon ↗
14
Murdle: Volume 1, 100 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles — gift idea

Murdle: Volume 1, 100 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles

G. T. Karber's first collection of 100 humorous whodunit logic puzzles, from the daily online game Murdle.

Ideal for: A puzzle fan who solves alone with a pencil

Why it works: 100 original puzzles · Deduction grids and witness statements · Low price

Skip if: The person wants a game for a group.

Score for this guide87/100 Black Friday −31 %
Black Friday deal $12.48 $18.00 on Nov 21, 11:11 PM
Order on Amazon ↗

Before you give: our advice

Budget, etiquette, wrapping: a few useful answers before you choose.

All our advice →

What Is the Best Kind of Murder Mystery Game to Give?

Match the format to the evening. A boxed case or a cold case file suits one or two people who like to read evidence, a social deduction game suits a party of four to twelve, a cooperative detective game suits a table that wants a long story, and a puzzle book suits someone who solves alone.

Which Games Can Be Played Alone or as a Couple?

The boxed cases, the cold case files and the logic puzzle books can be played solo, and several of them are described as suitable for a date. A party game such as Deception needs at least four players, so it is the one to skip for a couple.

Can You Replay a Murder Mystery Game?

Most boxed cases and escape-style card sets are solved once, then passed to another person. The logic puzzle books, the Sherlock Holmes campaign and the Deception party game give more evenings, because they hold many puzzles, ten cases or changing secret roles.

Murder mystery advent calendars: what is behind the doors

Murder on the Winterline Express is an interactive escape-room novel told across 24 days, with one puzzle woven into the story each day. Mystery Hunters' Stolen Mona Lisa Heist is an envelope-based case for ages 14 and up: one sealed envelope a day, digital evidence reached by QR code (the listing says internet is needed), a final verdict on the 24th and one-time play. Neither is reusable once solved. Both start on December 1 and calendars like these run out toward the end of November: order by November 25.

How we chose these picks

Here is how we chose these murder mystery games: each one clearly fits the recipient, and no two are the same kind of object.

Read our full selection method →

Frequently asked questions

What is the best murder mystery game for adults?

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders tops our ranking for a mystery fan who wants many evenings of cases. A boxed case such as Hunt A Killer, a cold case file such as Unsolved Case Files or a cooperative game such as Chronicles of Crime are strong alternatives.

What is a good murder mystery game for two people?

A boxed case or a cold case file can be played by two people, and the logic puzzle books can be shared.

What is a good murder mystery game for a party?

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong is built for four to twelve players with secret roles and 20-minute rounds.

Can a murder mystery game be played alone?

Yes, boxed cases, cold case files and logic puzzle books like Murdle and Murdoku can be played solo.

Is there a murder mystery advent calendar?

Yes. Murder on the Winterline Express is a 24-day murder mystery advent book, one puzzle a day until the last stop, and Mystery Hunters' Mona Lisa heist is an envelope case for ages 14 and up with digital evidence by QR code. Both are one-time puzzles: order by November 25 to open the first door on December 1.

Is there a murder mystery game for Christmas?

The two advent calendars are the seasonal picks, and any boxed case works as a Christmas gift for a mystery fan; the Sherlock Holmes campaign gives the most evenings.

See also

Gifts for Puzzle Lovers: The 17 Best Jigsaw Puzzles and Brain Teasers, Ranked (2026)

A puzzle lover wants a picture worth finishing and a piece count that matches their patience. Our ranking compares 17 puzzles and brain teasers for adults, from a Ravensburger magical deer and a custom photo puzzle to a 2000-piece Harry Potter tapestry, an advent puzzle, an escape-room box and a Murdle logic book. They run from about $12 to $45. Prices are indicative and change on Amazon.

Party Board Games: The 12 Best for Adults, Ranked (2026)

The best party board games for adults get a whole group playing within minutes, keep everyone in until the end and stay clean enough for mixed company. Our top three are One Night Ultimate Werewolf, Wits & Wagers Deluxe and Dixit. These 12 games, one per mechanic, run from about $17 to $49; prices are indicative and change on Amazon.

Strategy Board Games: The 12 Best for Adults, Ranked (2026)

The best strategy board games for adults are won by planning rather than luck, and the right one depends on how much the player already plays. Our top three are 7 Wonders Duel, Lost Cities and Dune: Imperium. These 12 games, one per mechanic and from light to heavy, run from about $21 to $67; prices are indicative and change on Amazon.

Gifts for the Whole Family: The 13 Best Shared Gifts for Everyone at Home, Ranked (2026)

When you buy one gift for a whole household, the best choice is something they can use together: a game, a puzzle, a family activity or a treat to share. Our ranking compares 13 shared gifts, from a card game and a tile game to a camera-based family console, a 1,000-piece puzzle, an escape-room puzzle box, a tie-dye kit and a cookie tin. They run from about $14 to $300. Prices are indicative and change on Amazon.

Best Puzzle Advent Calendars of 2026: Jigsaws, Murder Mysteries and Escape Games

The EXIT: The Game advent calendar leads this ranking of eleven puzzle calendars, followed by Hidden Games' time-travel adventure and The Advent Calendar Challenge, a pen-and-paper game book for two. The list covers three kinds of challenge, escape games, mystery books and jigsaws, for a teen or adult who likes puzzles. For each one we give what is behind the 24 doors, the age or time per day where the maker states it, and whether it can be replayed. Most are one-time puzzles, and they run out toward the end of November: order by November 25.

The 13 Best Puzzle Boxes for Adults: Escape Room Boxes, Money Boxes and Trick Boxes (2026)

iDventure Cluebox Nautilus leads this ranking of 13 puzzle boxes, followed by iDventure Cluebox Camelot and iDventure Cluebox PRO Sherlock's Camera. A puzzle box hides a compartment behind a series of moves, and these boxes open in different ways: an escape-room sequence, a marble maze, a jigsaw you assemble first, a combination lock and a trick that has to be discovered. For each box we give the play time the maker states, the age, whether it can be reassembled for the next player and what the hidden compartment can hold, so a cash gift or a ring can be earned rather than handed over.

← All guides