New Baby Gift Ideas: Plush & puppets
13 top-rated new baby gifts : plush & puppets, from $6 to $66. Our picks include Jellycat Bashful Tulip Pink Bunny, Ms. Rachel Herbie Cuddle & Comfort Friend and Ms. Rachel Surprise Learning Box with 6 soft a.
No gift matches all of these: widen the budget or remove an effect.
13 gift ideas
Jellycat Bashful Tulip Pink Bunny, Medium 12"
Jellycat's iconic Bashful Bunny in tulip pink, 12 inches, with velvet-soft fur and long floppy ears.
Ms. Rachel Herbie Cuddle & Comfort Friend, 11-inch plush for ages 6 months and up
Herbie from Ms. Rachel's videos as an 11-inch machine-washable plush by Gund Baby, for ages 6 months and up.
Ms. Rachel Surprise Learning Box with 6 soft accessories
A peek-a-boo box with four learning scenes and six soft surprises, from Ms. Rachel for babies.
Cate and Levi Polar Fleece Dog Hand Puppet
A 12-inch handmade fleece dog puppet from a family-owned shop in Toronto.
Jellycat Otto Sausage Dog, medium plush
A long, floppy-eared dachshund plush in dark chocolate fur with caramel muzzle and legs.
Jellycat Amuseables Pink and White Marshmallows, 3.5-inch plush
A pair of cheeky pink and white Jellycat marshmallows with praline cord boots and a satin ribbon, 3.5 inches tall.
The Petting Zoo Cownose Stingray Plush, 12 Inch
A 12-inch floppy cownose ray plush with a white underbelly, made from recycled plastic bottles.
GUND PAW Patrol Marshall 6-Inch Plush Toy
A 6-inch GUND Marshall plush in his red fireman uniform, surface washable, for ages 1 and up.
Disney Baby Toy Story Large 8-inch Stuffed Animal Plush Woody
An 8-inch Woody plush with a cow-print vest, checked shirt, boots and a stitched cowboy hat.
Squishmallows 11-Inch HugMees CoComelon Baby JJ
A medium-size HugMees plush of JJ in his pajama onesie, ultrasoft, with open arms for hugs.
Steiff DC Superhero Teddy Bear (Superman)
A 12-inch Steiff teddy bear dressed as Superman, with a cape and an embroidered S-shield.
BARRADO Asterix Character Cuddly Toy, 30 cm, Super Soft Quality
A 30 cm official Asterix plush in the Barrado range with Asterix, Obelix, Panoramix and Idefix, minimum age 0 months.
Kids Preferred Peppa Pig 12-Inch Plush for Babies
A super-soft 12-inch Peppa plush with embroidered details and beans in the bottom, for babies from 0 months.
Our guides on this topic
-
The 60 Best Christmas Gifts for Toddlers and Preschoolers, Ranked (2026)
A toddler's Christmas list usually comes down to two things: something to press, sing along to or pretend with, and something big enough to ride. These 60 picks cover both, plus building sets and a first balance bike, from a under $15 song-and-counting book to an $50 to $100 push car and a $100 to $200 Toniebox farm bundle for the one big present.
-
Stuffed Animals for Kids: The 14 Best Plush Toys and Cuddly Gifts, Ranked (2026)
A stuffed animal is a gift a child keeps for years, so the best ones are soft, the right size and tied to something the child already loves. Our top pick is the Disney Store Toy Story Woody plush, ahead of the Aurora Dr. Seuss Grinch and the Bluey Heeler family set. The ranking compares 14 plush toys for children, from a small fox with a finger puppet storybook and a Jellycat bunny to Disney, Bluey, Pokemon and Minecraft characters, an interactive monkey, a Sesame Street hand puppet, a pocket-size Tickle Me Elmo and a 59-inch panda. They run from about $16 to $100. Prices are indicative and change on Amazon.