ChooseTheGift

New Baby Gift Ideas: Plush & puppets

13 top-rated new baby gifts : plush & puppets, from $6 to $66. Our picks include Jellycat Bashful Tulip Pink Bunny, Ms. Rachel Herbie Cuddle & Comfort Friend and Ms. Rachel Surprise Learning Box with 6 soft a.

13 gift ideas

2026 trend
Jellycat Bashful Tulip Pink Bunny, Medium 12" — gift idea Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Christmas

Jellycat Bashful Tulip Pink Bunny, Medium 12"

Jellycat's iconic Bashful Bunny in tulip pink, 12 inches, with velvet-soft fur and long floppy ears.

88/100
$37.95 on Nov 22, 11:50 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Ms. Rachel Herbie Cuddle & Comfort Friend, 11-inch plush for ages 6 months and up — gift idea Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets New Baby

Ms. Rachel Herbie Cuddle & Comfort Friend, 11-inch plush for ages 6 months and up

Herbie from Ms. Rachel's videos as an 11-inch machine-washable plush by Gund Baby, for ages 6 months and up.

88/100
$14.99 on Nov 22, 10:40 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Ms. Rachel Surprise Learning Box with 6 soft accessories — gift idea Black Friday −36 % Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets New Baby

Ms. Rachel Surprise Learning Box with 6 soft accessories

A peek-a-boo box with four learning scenes and six soft surprises, from Ms. Rachel for babies.

87/100
Black Friday deal $20.99 $32.99 on Nov 22, 10:20 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Cate and Levi Polar Fleece Dog Hand Puppet — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Cate and Levi Polar Fleece Dog Hand Puppet

A 12-inch handmade fleece dog puppet from a family-owned shop in Toronto.

79/100
$23.99 on Nov 22, 10:20 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
2026 trend
Jellycat Otto Sausage Dog, medium plush — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Jellycat Otto Sausage Dog, medium plush

A long, floppy-eared dachshund plush in dark chocolate fur with caramel muzzle and legs.

85/100
$65.78 on Nov 22, 10:10 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
2026 trend
Jellycat Amuseables Pink and White Marshmallows, 3.5-inch plush — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets New Baby

Jellycat Amuseables Pink and White Marshmallows, 3.5-inch plush

A pair of cheeky pink and white Jellycat marshmallows with praline cord boots and a satin ribbon, 3.5 inches tall.

85/100
Budget$30 to $50
See the price on Amazon ↗
The Petting Zoo Cownose Stingray Plush, 12 Inch — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

The Petting Zoo Cownose Stingray Plush, 12 Inch

A 12-inch floppy cownose ray plush with a white underbelly, made from recycled plastic bottles.

68/100
$16.99 on Nov 22, 09:00 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
GUND PAW Patrol Marshall 6-Inch Plush Toy — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

GUND PAW Patrol Marshall 6-Inch Plush Toy

A 6-inch GUND Marshall plush in his red fireman uniform, surface washable, for ages 1 and up.

84/100
$6.32 on Nov 22, 09:40 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Disney Baby Toy Story Large 8-inch Stuffed Animal Plush Woody — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Disney Baby Toy Story Large 8-inch Stuffed Animal Plush Woody

An 8-inch Woody plush with a cow-print vest, checked shirt, boots and a stitched cowboy hat.

83/100
$13.00 on Nov 22, 09:20 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Squishmallows 11-Inch HugMees CoComelon Baby JJ — gift idea
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Squishmallows 11-Inch HugMees CoComelon Baby JJ

A medium-size HugMees plush of JJ in his pajama onesie, ultrasoft, with open arms for hugs.

83/100
$20.54 on Nov 22, 09:30 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Steiff DC Superhero Teddy Bear (Superman) — gift idea Black Friday −20 % Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Steiff DC Superhero Teddy Bear (Superman)

A 12-inch Steiff teddy bear dressed as Superman, with a cape and an embroidered S-shield.

86/100
Black Friday deal $39.20 $49.00 on Nov 22, 10:30 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
BARRADO Asterix Character Cuddly Toy, 30 cm, Super Soft Quality — gift idea Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

BARRADO Asterix Character Cuddly Toy, 30 cm, Super Soft Quality

A 30 cm official Asterix plush in the Barrado range with Asterix, Obelix, Panoramix and Idefix, minimum age 0 months.

87/100
$39.60 on Nov 22, 09:30 AM
Order on Amazon ↗
Kids Preferred Peppa Pig 12-Inch Plush for Babies — gift idea Favorite
Toys & Interactive Gadgets Birthday

Kids Preferred Peppa Pig 12-Inch Plush for Babies

A super-soft 12-inch Peppa plush with embroidered details and beans in the bottom, for babies from 0 months.

86/100
$17.99 on Nov 22, 09:20 AM
Order on Amazon ↗

Our guides on this topic

← Back to New Baby Gifts